Dark chocolate base with tiny chunks of Valrhona "magicked" dark chocolate. Contains egg, dairy, coconut oil.
Vanilla Bean
$12.5
Our classic vanilla ice cream base made with real Madagascar vanilla beans. Contains dairy and eggs.
Cookies & Cream
$12.5
Sweet cream ice cream base with chunks of chocolate cookie. You might be interested to learn that Cookies and Cream was invented here in New York City. We were surprised to learn that it was invented at all we assumed it evolved from the ooze with us humans. Contains dairy, egg, and gluten.
Sprinkles
$12.5
Sweet cream ice cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. Contains dairy, eggs, and sprinkles.
Cookies & Mint
$12.5
Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, and gluten.
Add-Ons
Sugar cones
$2.0
4 sugar cones
Freshly made waffle cone
$2.0
We make all our waffle cones in house daily! Allergens: dairy, egg, gluten
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.0
1 chewy chocolate chip. cookie
Vegan Flavors
Vegan Grasshopper
$12.5
Vegan chocolate cashew-based ice cream flavored with mint and spun with tons of chocolate sandwich cookies. Allergens: cashew, gluten.
Beverages
Boylan's Soda
$5.0
12oz Glass Bottles
Milkshakes
$11.0
16 oz. milkshake made with our homemade ice cream.
OddFellows Favorites
Chocotorta
$12.5
Sour cream and cream cheese ice cream base with chunks of dulce de leche and chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
$12.5
Passionfruit ice cream base with candied apricots and pistachios. Contains dairy, egg, pistachio.
Peanut Butter S'mores
$12.5
You wanted a hit. This is how we do hits. Our collaboration ice cream flavor with LCD Soundsystems. Peanut butter ice cream base with graham cracker crumbs, magicked dark chocolate, and burnt marshmallows. It won't be your baby till you take it home. Contains dairy, egg, gluten, coconut oil, gelatin.
Oddfellows Ice Cream Dumbo Menu
Dark Chocolate Chunk
$12.5
Dark chocolate base with tiny chunks of Valrhona "magicked" dark chocolate. Contains egg, dairy, coconut oil.
Vanilla Bean
$12.5
Our classic vanilla ice cream base made with real Madagascar vanilla beans. Contains dairy and eggs.
Sweet Cream and Sprinkles
$12.5
Sweet cream ice cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. Contains dairy, eggs, and sprinkles.
Cookies and Cream
$12.0
Sweet cream ice cream base with chunks of chocolate cookie. You might be interested to learn that Cookies and Cream was invented here in New York City. We were surprised to learn that it was invented at all we assumed it evolved from the ooze with us humans. Contains dairy, egg, and gluten.
Cookies and Mint
$12.0
Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, and gluten.
Chocotorta
$12.5
Sour cream and cream cheese ice cream base with chunks of dulce de leche and chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio Pint
$12.0
Saffron passionfruit ice cream base with candied apricots and pistachios. Contains dairy, egg, pistachio.
PB S'mores
$12.0
You wanted a hit. This is how we do hits. Our collaboration ice cream flavor with LCD Soundsystems. Peanut butter ice cream base with graham cracker crumbs, magicked dark chocolate, and burnt marshmallows. It won't be your baby till you take it home. Contains dairy, egg, gluten, coconut oil, gelatin.
Cookies + Mint Pint
$12.0
Mint ice cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
Vegan Grasshopper
$12.5
Vegan chocolate cashew-based ice cream flavored with mint and spun with tons of chocolate sandwich cookies. Allergens: cashew, gluten.
Coffee Crunch
$12.0
Our most popular coffee-based, crunchy ice cream! Coffee base with coffee soil almond flour, sugar, salt, coffee, flour, and butter. Contains dairy, eggs, almonds.
Holiday Movie Night
Banoffee Pie
$12.5
A banana ice cream with swirls of rich dulce de leche and graham cracker crust crumbled in.
Buddi's Spaghetti Sundae
$12.5
Maple Ice cream packed with a mix of chocolate cookie crumbs, mini marshmallows, M&M's, Sno-Caps and corn nuts
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice Cream Sandwich
$8.0
An ice cream flavor of your choice between two chewy chocolate chip cookies